Home Mr Old Man ONE LOT OR TWO LOTS: DOES THE METHOD OF SENDING DOCUMENTS AFFECT COMPLIANCE?

ONE LOT OR TWO LOTS: DOES THE METHOD OF SENDING DOCUMENTS AFFECT COMPLIANCE?

11 min read
0
0
0

Introduction

Requirements in an LC concerning the submission of documents “in one lot” or “in two lots” may appear straightforward, but they can raise some interesting questions when documents are received separately or when a subsequent presentation is made to cure discrepancies.

In this Q&A, we look at three situations: documents arriving in two separate lots despite a “one lot” requirement; additional documents submitted after an initial discrepant presentation; and documents being sent in one lot when the LC requires two lots.

The key issue is whether the method of transmission itself creates a discrepancy, or whether we should distinguish it from the concept of a presentation under the UCP 600.

Cu De River. Photo: Mr. Old Man

QUESTION

Dear Mr. Old Man,

I would like to seek your advice regarding the presentation of documents under a Letter of Credit (LC) in the following scenarios:

Scenario 1:

The LC stipulates that all documents must be presented “in one lot” to the issuing bank.

Scenario 1a:

The issuing bank receives all the documents in two separate lots, arriving three days apart. Upon examination and consolidation of both lots, the documents are found to be fully compliant with the LC terms.

My question is: Is this presentation considered discrepant because the LC required the documents to be presented in a single lot?

Scenario 1b:

The issuing bank receives a set of documents “in one lot” as required by the LC, but the documents contain discrepancies. The issuing bank notifies the nominated bank and the beneficiary accordingly. Three days later, the issuing bank receives additional documents intended to rectify the previous discrepancies. The subsequent submission is made within the applicable presentation period and the additional documents comply with the LC terms.

In this case, should this be considered a submission in “two lots”?

Does it violate the LC’s requirement that documents be submitted “in one lot”?

Scenario 2:

The LC stipulates that all documents must be presented “in two lots,” with an interval of three days between them, to the issuing bank.

If the issuing bank receives only a single lot, yet the content and quantity of the documents are fully compliant with the LC (i.e., no documents are missing), is this considered a discrepancy because the documents were not submitted in two lots as required by the LC?

I look forward to your response.

Best regards,

M.

_______

ANSWER

Dear M.,

Thank you for your question.

Scenario 1

  1. a) The answer to your specific scenario is NO.

The fact that the documents arrive in two separate lots does not, by itself, make the presentation discrepant if the two lots together constitute a complying presentation and are received within the applicable presentation period.

For example, if the first lot does not contain all the documents required by the LC, the issuing bank may not be able to determine compliance based solely on that lot. However, if the second lot is received within the applicable presentation period and, together with the first lot, the documents constitute a complying presentation, the documents should be examined as a whole.

Accordingly, in the scenario described, the fact that the documents arrived in two consecutive lots, rather than in one lot, would not in itself constitute a discrepancy, even though the LC stipulated that the documents should be sent “in one lot.”

  1. b) The answer remains NO, although this is a different situation from Scenario 1a.

Once the first presentation has been refused because of discrepancies, the subsequent submission of documents intended to cure those discrepancies should be treated as a subsequent presentation, provided that it is made within the applicable presentation period and otherwise complies with the LC and the applicable rules.

The fact that the documents are physically received on different occasions does not necessarily mean that the beneficiary has made a presentation in “two lots” in the sense contemplated by a clause requiring documents to be sent in two mailings.

In other words, a requirement to send documents “in one lot” should not necessarily be confused with the concept of a presentation under the UCP 600. A subsequent presentation made to cure discrepancies is a separate presentation and should be examined accordingly.

Scenario 2

The answer is NO, assuming that the requirement to send the documents “in two lots” is intended merely to prescribe the method of transmission rather than to require two separate presentations of different documents.

If the issuing bank receives all the documents required by the LC in a single lot and the documents otherwise constitute a complying presentation, the mere fact that they were not physically divided into two mailings should not, in itself, constitute a documentary discrepancy.

Historically, requiring documents to be sent in two mailings was used as a precautionary measure. The purpose was to reduce the risk that all the documents might be lost in transit: if the first mailing was lost, the second mailing would still be available to the importer for taking delivery of the goods.

That practice has become less compelling with modern courier services and reliable shipment tracking. Moreover, sending documents in two separate mailings imposes additional costs on the beneficiary. Consequently, beneficiaries and banks may reasonably object to an LC requirement to send documents “IN TWO LOTS.”

For further reference, please find below the relevant analysis and conclusion from ICC Opinion R415:

QUOTE

Analysis and Conclusion

When an issuing bank requests that documents be sent in two mailings, the first mailing should consist of at least one original of all of the required documents. The second mailing will consist of one copy of the documents presented, where this is possible – i.e. under the credit terms a document may only be produced in the singular and therefore would be included within the first mailing – and, if applicable, an original bill of lading. This first mailing should provide the issuing bank with the ability to review the documents on the basis that the second mailing will only contain copies (or further original(s)) of documents already received.

If an issuing bank has chosen this method for the delivery of documents, it must be prepared to provide a rejection notice in accordance with Article 14 of the UCP 500 based upon the content of the first mailing. To do otherwise could give rise to an inordinate delay in reviewing the documents should the second mailing be delayed or lost in transit.

UNQUOTE

Best regards,

Mr. Old Man

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • WHERE DOCUMENTS ARE REQUIRED TO BE SENT IN TWO CONSECUTIVE LOTS

    QUERY Xin chào Mr Old Man, Em tên Minh, xin được phép nhờ anh giúp em tình huống về việc g…
Load More Related Articles
Load More By Mr Old Man
Load More In Mr Old Man

Check Also

LÊ KHẢ GIÁP: GÓC NHÌN TỪ MR. OLD MAN

Mr. Old Man biết đến Lê Khả Giáp từ những thước phim anh đi bộ, lầm lũi kéo chiếc xe tự ch…